Rejection comes in many forms. Sometimes it’s dramatic and heartbreak-inducing, and other times it’s subtle and inconsequential. Either way, female instinct always gets the better of me and leads to overanalyze why things played out the way they did. Typically I’m able to take away some lesson from the situation, see it as an opportunity for self-improvement, and eventually I’m over it and it’s on to the next one.
One particular rejection has stood out from the rest. During fall quarter something unheard of happened, and I actually met an attractive guy in one of my science classes. At first I was wary, given the fact that he always talked to one guy who looked like he auditioned for Jersey Shore but was turned down for being too guido. However, I was willing to overlook the odd contrast between his J. Crew flannel and J. Shore’s wifebeaters and started strategically sitting close to him so we’d always end up partnered for group work.
By the time finals week rolled around we were undeniably flirting, but we’d never exchanged numbers and I was convinced that I was never going to see him again. However, I was soon proven wrong, as I went out to the bars to celebrate the end of finals with my roommate, only to run into him and J. Shore. Any doubts I’d previously had about his interest level disappeared once he started gushing abut how I was “so amazing” and that he couldn’t believe it had taken him so long to muster up the courage to talk to me. All very flattering, to say the least.
After the bar closed J. Crew ended up at my apartment and initiated with the kiss, which would’ve escalated into a makeout session if we hadn’t been interrupted by J. Shore reuniting with us. The three of us were just talking and hanging out, until J. Crew’s alcohol consumption got the better of him and he wound up puking in my bathroom. Eventually J. Crew emerged after finishing his business and literally ran out of my apartment, leaving his phone, wallet, etc for J. Shore to collect. The next morning I woke up to discover that J. Crew’s sweater had been left behind in all the madness. We met up briefly the next day so I could return it, and after making a bit of small talk he paused and said “So…could we just pretend that last night never happened? Because based on my memory of the night it really didn’t,” which I interpreted as a rude way to say that he regretted kissing me and it wasn’t going to happen again. Naturally, I was shocked when he texted me that night to ask if I wanted to go to a party with him and later tried to make New Year’s Eve plans with me.
Unfortunately neither of those plans worked, and we wound up having to wait until the start of the following quarter to hang out. When we did finally meet up, I went over to his apartment for tea and after hours of talking, it seemed like we had great chemistry. But rather than being a jumping point for something more, this turned out to be the pinnacle of our interaction. The next time we hung out him and his visiting cousin accompanied me to my friend’s party. It was absolutely packed with people I know when we arrived, so I was doing my best to introduce them both to people who came up to say hi, but to no avail. One thing to be said about J. Crew is that while he’s pretty chill, he’s also fairly introverted and pretty judgmental of people, and I got the feeling that he cared more about hanging out with his cousin than engaging anyone in conversation. At one point my drunk friend walked up and wordlessly grabbed my face, kissed me on the cheek, and left, and I was convinced that the evening may fare better if we left and went to the party J. Crew’s cousin suggested. I was wrong. It may have been a party at some point, but when we arrived it was nothing but a sad showing of five very sober people, and we received about as much welcome as a group of random guys trying to crash a frat party. After about fifteen minutes J. Crew’s cousin fell asleep on the couch and J. Crew suggested that him and I leave.
It didn’t seem right to leave his cousin to fend for himself, but I figured J. Crew knew best and at that our alone time could salvage the night. Wrong again- all of my advances were spurned. I tried to link arms with him but he remained completely stiff (not in the good way) and unresponsive. I asked if I could wear his jacket on the walk back and he did loan it to me, but only after making me feel as if that was one of the most high maintenance requests I could’ve made. The final straw came when he acted like walking me home was a huge nuisance. After what felt like one of the longest walks ever I returned his jacket, made a comment about not wanting to be an inconvenience, and went inside without even getting a peck goodbye. Ten minutes later he texted me, saying “Sorry to be such a disappointment. I just can’t help it sometimes,” to which I responded that I wasn’t sure what he wanted me to say, but that I wouldn’t have described him as a disappointment.
And that was it. I never heard from him again and later discovered that he went as far as deleting me as a Facebook friend. In hindsight this wasn’t a huge loss, but that doesn’t satisfy my curiosity about what killed his attraction and interest. I would love to hear any input as to what J. Crew’s deal was, perhaps an objective mind could solve this mystery.
Tags: boys, college dating, dating, make out, rejection, relationships






